A learner says that one quarter is larger than one third because four is larger than three. Before correcting the symbol, ask them to draw the two fractions using equal-sized wholes. The drawing gives you a way to discuss what the denominator means.
This 25-minute online tutoring lesson moves from paper strips to equivalent fractions and an independent explanation. It fits the focus of Common Core 4.NF.A.1 and 4.NF.A.2 on equivalence, comparisons referring to the same whole, and mathematical justification. The suggested timings are a lesson plan you can adjust to the learner. Common Core grade 4 fraction standards
Make the whole visible before comparing
Use the first four minutes to prepare two equal rectangles on a shared whiteboard, or two equal-length paper strips of the same width. Duplicate one digital rectangle to make the second. If you use paper, cut or mark both from the same template and align their edges.
Ask the learner to show you one whole. Then divide one rectangle into three equal parts and the other into four equal parts. Shade one part on each. Ask which shaded part is larger and how the partitioning explains it.
For these equal wholes, 1/3 > 1/4. Dividing the whole into more equal parts makes each part smaller. If a learner’s thirds are unequal, redraw the partitions before using the model to support a comparison.

Keep the whole visible when switching representations. Three quarters of a large sheet and two thirds of a smaller sheet describe shares of different objects. To compare the fractions as shares of one unit, use the same-sized whole for both models.
Compare three quarters and two thirds in equal parts
Spend six minutes comparing 3/4 and 2/3. Shade three quarters of one whole and two thirds of an equal whole. Ask the learner to predict which shaded amount is larger before calculating.
Now subdivide each quarter into three equal pieces. Each original whole contains twelve equal pieces, and the three shaded quarters contain nine of them. Record 3/4 = 9/12.
On the other model, subdivide each third into four equal pieces. Its whole also contains twelve equal pieces, with eight shaded. Record 2/3 = 8/12.
Because the wholes match, the twelfths are the same size. Nine twelfths is greater than eight twelfths, so 3/4 > 2/3. Ask the learner to point to the one-twelfth difference on the models.
Connect the drawings to the calculations. Multiplying both the numerator and denominator of 3/4 by three gives 9/12. Multiplying both parts of 2/3 by four gives 8/12. The number of pieces changes while the shaded share of each whole stays the same.
Use the explanation to choose the next prompt
Allow six minutes for checking the reasoning. Ask the learner to explain a comparison and use their answer to choose a follow-up.
- “A bigger denominator makes a bigger fraction.” Return to one third and one quarter of equal wholes. Ask how many pieces make a whole and compare the size of one piece.
- “I multiplied the four by three, so 3/4 is 3/12.” Shade both claims on equal wholes. Three quarters covers nine twelfths. Ask which shaded area changed when only the denominator changed.
- “They have the same denominator now, so they are equal.” Ask the learner to count shaded twelfths in each model. Equal-sized pieces can occur in different quantities.
- “Three quarters is bigger because three is bigger than two.” Ask whether that rule would make 3/8 larger than 2/4. Rewriting 2/4 as 4/8 shows that 3/8 < 2/4. Bring the explanation back to the size and number of equal parts.
Keep the learner’s original working available while they revise it. Ask them to identify the step they changed and explain why.

Ask for one complete comparison
Use four minutes for a guided explanation of 2/3 and 8/12. A learner can partition each third into four equal pieces to show 2/3 = 8/12. This time the correct comparison symbol is equality.
Ask for three pieces of information in a spoken or written response. What is the whole? How were the equivalent fractions made? What comparison follows? A possible explanation is, “Both strips represent the same whole. I divided each third into four equal pieces, so the two shaded thirds became eight twelfths. The fractions are equal.”
If drawing or dragging on a whiteboard is difficult, the learner can describe the partitions while you draw them and then confirm whether the model matches their explanation.
Finish with a fresh comparison
For the last five minutes, ask the learner to compare 5/6 and 7/12 independently. Request a model or equivalent fractions and a sentence explaining the result.
The expected comparison is 5/6 = 10/12, and 10/12 > 7/12, so 5/6 > 7/12. Check that the learner divided each sixth into two equal pieces and kept the whole unchanged.
Use the response to choose the next lesson’s starting point. If the equivalence is correct but the comparison symbol is reversed, ask them to read the comparison aloud. If only one part of the fraction was multiplied, return to the partitioned strip. For another tutoring routine built around a model and an explanation, use the worked ratio lesson. Online ratio tutoring guide
If learners use a browser whiteboard or worksheet, test its links before class. In Focus Room, allow the required hostnames in the participating browser during the active extension session, and review the learner’s model in your usual teaching tools. Focus Room website-rule setup

